“海国新奇妇有髭”——晚清域外游记中有关妇人生须的“观察”与跨文化想象
“It's Strange, Women Overseas Have Whiskers”: Observations of Women's Facial Hair in Late-Qing Foreign Travelogues and Cross-Cultural Imaginations
-
摘要: 在晚清域外游记中,有一种对西方女性的“观察”,即认为西方女性是“生须”的。这一记述之所以值得关注,是因为记述者都是“亲眼所见”,而且这种描述并非孤例,散见于许多文献之中,如张祖翼的《伦敦竹枝词》、王以宣的《法京纪事诗》、张德彝的《三述奇》、袁祖志的《瀛海采问纪实》等。西方文献中有关于女性生须的记录,多以神秘、畸形和猎奇的态度记述之。中国史籍中有关妇人生须的记载史不绝书,或用以描述蛮夷之貌,或用以暗示灾异之兆,或用以呈现报应之果,或用以彰显祥瑞之象。总之,中西文献中女性生须的记载都可归为本文化中“异质”因素。在晚清中西交通之后,出洋的中国人将对于本文化“异质”要素的理解转化为对于“异文化”的观察。有关西方妇人生须的“观察”,虽为记述者之“亲见”,但“观察”之结果是由观察者的文化立场所决定的,其中包含着大量想象的成分。何天爵在《本色中国人》中所记述的一则误解事件,则足以证明这种对异文化的“在场观察”,根本上也受到了跨文化“想象”的影响。文化观察的结果,并不因观察距离的拉进而改变,异文化的形象,实质上就是一种“社会集体想象物”。Abstract: In travelogues of the late Qing Dynasty, there was an "observation" made about Western women; namely, that Western women were born with facial hair. The reason why this record is worth attention is that the narrator "saw it with his own eyes," and this description is not an isolated example, which can be found in many documents, such as Zhang Zuyi's "London Zhuzhi Ci," Wang Yixuan's "Fa Jing Ji Shi," Zhang Deyi's "San Shu Qi," Yuan Zuzhi's "Ying Hai Cai Wen Ji Shi," and others. There are records of female facial hair in Western literature, which are mostly described as mysterious, abnormal, and curious. In Chinese historical records, there are many records about women's facial hair, either to describe the appearance of barbarians, to indicate the omens of disasters, to show the results of retribution, or to show the image of auspiciousness. In short, the records of female facial hair in Chinese and Western literature can be classified as "heterogeneous" culturally. Although the observation of Western women's facial hair is the narrator's personal view, the result of observation is determined by the observer's cultural position, which contains many imaginative elements. A misunderstanding described by Chaster Holcombe in The Real Chinaman is enough to prove that this kind of "on-the-spot observation" of different cultures is also fundamentally influenced by cross-cultural "imagination." The result of cultural observation is not changed by the distance of observation. The image of different cultures is essentially a kind of "social collective imagination."
-
Key words:
- Women's facial hair /
- San Shu Qi /
- Jing Hua Yuan /
- Imagology
-
[1] 蔡俊著:《中国近现代文学中的洋人形象》,南昌:江西人民出版社,2013年。 [2] [CAI Jun. Zhongguo jinxiandai wenxue zhong de yangren xingxiang (The Image of Foreigners in Modern Chinese Literature). Nanchang:Jiangxi People's Publishing House, 2013.] [3] 褚人获撰:《坚瓠集》,上海古籍出版社编:《清代笔记小说大观》 (二),上海:上海古籍出版社,2007年。 [4] [CHU Renhuo. Jian hu ji. In Qingdai biji xiaoshuo daguan (Grand View of Qing Dynasty Literary Sketches). Shanghai:Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House, 2007.] [5] 费振刚等辑校:《全汉赋》,北京大学出版社,1993年。 [6] [FEI Zhengang et al., eds. Quanhan fu (Collected Rhyme-Prose of Han Dynasty). Beijing:Peking University Press, 1993.] [德] 顾彬著,曹卫东编译:《关于"异"的研究》,北京:北京大学出版社,1997年。 [8] [Kubin, Wolfgang. Guanyu "yi" de yanjiu (A Study on "Difference"). Translated by CAO Weidong. Beijing:Peking University Press,1997.] [英] 何天爵著,冯岩译:《本色中国人》,南京:译林出版社,2014年。 [10] [Holcombe, Chaster. Bense Zhongguo ren (The Real Chinaman). Translated by FENG Yan. Nanjing:Yilin Press, 2014.] [法] 基亚著,颜保译:《比较文学》,北京:北京大学出版社,1983年。 [12] [Guyard, Marius-François. Bijiao wenxue (Comparative Literature). Translated by YAN Bao. Beijing:Peking University Press, 1983.] [13] 姜智芹著:《镜像后的文化冲突与文化认同:英美文学中的中国形象》,北京:中华书局,2008年。 [14] [JIANG Zhiqin. Jingxiang hou de wenhua chongtu yu wenhua rentong:Yingmei wenxue zhong de Zhongguo xingxiang (Cultural Conflict and Cultural Identity in the Mirror:The Image of China in British and American Literature). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2008.] [法] 阿兰·科尔班(Alain Corbin)主编,杨剑译:《身体的历史》 (卷二:从法国大革命到第一次世界大战),上海:华东师范大学出版社,2013年。 [16] [Corbin, Alain. Shenti de lishi, juan er:cong Faguo dageming dao diyici shijie dazhan (The History of the Body, vol. 2: [17] From the French Revolution to the First World War). Translated by YANG Jian. Shanghai:East China Normal University Press, 2013.] [清] 李汝珍著,张友鹤校注:《镜花缘》,北京:人民文学出版社,2012年。 [19] [LI Ruzhen, ZHANG Youhe. Jinghua yuan (The Marriage of Flowers in the Mirror). Beijing:Beijing People's Publishing House, 2012.] [明]刘忭、[明]沈遴奇、[明]沈儆垣撰,陈国军点校:《续耳谭》,北京:文物出版社,2016。 [21] [LIU Bian, SHEN Linqi and SHEN Jingyuan. Xu er tan. Edited by CHEN Guojun. Beijing:Cultural Relics Publishing House, 2016.] [明]陆粲撰,谭棣华、陈稼禾点校:《庚巳编》,北京:中华书局,1987年。 [23] [LU Can, TAN Dihua and CHEN Jiahe, eds. Gengsi bian. Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 1987.] [24] 孟华主编:《比较文学形象学》,北京:北京大学出版社,2001年。 [25] [MENG Hua. Bijiao wenxue xingxiangxue (Imagology of Comparative Literature). Beijing:Peking University Press, 2001.] [26] 孟华著:《中国文学中的西方人形象》,合肥:安徽教育出版社,2006年。 [27] [——. Zhongguo wenxue zhong de xifangren xingxiang (Western Images in Chinese Literature). Hefei:Anhui Education Press, 2006.] [28] 钱锺书著:《七缀集》,北京:三联书店,2002年。 [29] [QIAN Zhongshu. Qi zhui ji (Seven Patches). Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2002.] [30] 丘良任、潘超、孙忠铨、丘进编:《中华竹枝词全编》,北京:北京出版社,2007年。 [31] [QIU Liangren, PAN Chao, SUN Zhongquan and QIU Jin, eds. Zhonghua zhuzhi ci quanbian (Complete Works of Chinese Zhuzhi Ci). Beijing:Beijing Press, 2007.] [32] 谭渊著:《德国文学中的中国女性形象》,武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017年。 [33] [TAN Yuan. Deguo wenxue zhong de Zhongguo nvxing xingxiang (Chinese Female Images in German Literature). Wuhan:Wuhan University Press, 2017.] [清]王初桐纂述,陈晓东整理:《奁史》,北京:文物出版社,2017年。 [35] [WANG Chutong, and CHEN Xiaodong, eds., Lianshi. Beijing:Cultural Relics Publishing House, 2017.] [36] 王汝良著:《中国文学中的印度形象研究》,北京:中华书局,2018年。 [37] [WANG Ruliang. Zhongguo wenxue zhong de Yindu xingxiang yanjiu (A Study on the Image of India in Chinese Literature). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2018.] [38] 王慎之、王子今辑:《清代海外竹枝词》,北京:北京大学出版社,1994年。 [39] [WANG Shenzhi, and WANG Zijin, eds. Qingdai haiwai zhuzhi ci (Overseas Zhuzhi Ci in Qing Dynasty). Beijing:Peking University Press, 1994.] [40] 王一樵著:《紫禁城里很有事:明清宫廷小人物的日常》,北京:中信出版社,2018年。 [41] [WANG Yiqiao. Zijincheng li henyou shi:Ming Qing gongting xiaorenwu de richang (The Forbidden City is Busy:Nobody's Daily Life in Imperial Palaces of the Ming and Qing Dynasties). Beijing:CITIC Press, 2018.] [42] 王以宣著,穆易校点:《法京纪事诗》,长沙:岳麓书社,2017年。 [43] [WANG Yixuan, MU Yi. Fajing jishi shi (The Chronicles of Fa Jing). Changsha:Yuelu Press, 2017.] [法] 乔治·维加埃罗(Georges Vigarello)主编,张竝、赵济鸿译:《身体的历史》 (卷一:从文艺复兴到启蒙运动),上海:华东师范大学出版社,2013年。 [45] [Vigarello, Georges. Shenti de lishi, juan yi:cong wenyifuxin dao qimengyundong (The History of the Body, vol. 1:From the Renaissance to the Enlightenment). Translated by ZHANG Bing and ZHAO Jihong. Shanghai:East China Nomal University Press, 2013.] [隋]萧吉撰:《五行大义》,南京:江苏古籍出版社,1988年。 [47] [XIAO Ji. Wuxingdayi. Nanjing:Jiangsu Chinese Classics Publishing House, 1988.] [48] 杨波:《晚清旅西记述研究》,河南大学博士论文,2010年。 [49] [YANG Bo. Wan Qing lvxi jishu yanjiu (A Study on Traveling West in the Late Qing Dynasty). PhD diss., Henan University, 2010.] [50] 杨昕著:《〈朝天录〉中的明代中国人形象研究》,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2016年。 [51] [YANG Xin. Chaotian lu zhong de Mingdai Zhongguoren xingxiang yanjiu (The Study on the Chinese Image in Ming Dynasty in Chaotian Lu). Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press, 2016.] [明] 张岱著,李小龙整理:《夜航船》,北京:中华书局,2012年。 [53] [ZHANG Dai, and LI Xiaolong, eds. Yehangchuan (Night Vessel). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2012.] [54] 张英进:《美国电影中华人形象的演变》,《二十一世纪》,2004年6月号(总第83期),第85-94页。 [55] [ZHANG Yingjin. "Meiguo dianying zhong huaren xingxiang de yanbian" (The Evolution of Chinese Characters in American Films). Ershiyi shiji (21st Century) 83(June 2004):85-94.] [56] 张哲俊著:《中国古代文学中的日本形象研究》,北京:中华书局,2004年。 [57] [ZHANG Zhejun. Zhongguo gudai wenxue zhong de Riben xingxiang yanjiu (A Study on the Image of Japan in Ancient Chinese Literature). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2004.] [58] 钟叔河主编:《走向世界丛书续编》,长沙:岳麓书社,2017年。 [59] [ZHONG Shuhe, ed. Zouxiang shijie congshu xubian (A Sequel towards the World Series). Changsha:Yuelu Press, 2017.] [60] ——:《走向世界丛书》 (修订本),长沙:岳麓书社,2008年。 [61] [——. Zouxiang shijie congshu (Towards the World Series[Rev.]). Changsha:Yuelu Press, 2008.] [62] 周宁著:《天朝遥远:西方的中国形象研究》,北京:北京大学出版社,2006年。 [63] [ZHOU Ning. Tianchao yaoyuan:xifang de Zhongguo xingxiang yanjiu (Remote Empire:A Study on the Image of China in the West). Beijing:Peking University Press, 2006.]
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 415
- HTML全文浏览量: 31
- PDF下载量: 381
- 被引次数: 0