民族关系的调适与文学创作的“现实意义”——反思近年来有关奢香夫人的几部戏剧影视作品

邵文苑

doi:10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20236207

民族关系的调适与文学创作的“现实意义”——反思近年来有关奢香夫人的几部戏剧影视作品

doi: 10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20236207

邵文苑^,

上海大学

基金项目:

本文的前期研究作为笔者博士论文研究的一部分，得到过国家留学基金（2015—2018）的资助，后期撰写在上海大学“泮池计划”（2021—）的支持下完成。

详细信息

作者简介:
邵文苑,美国俄亥俄州立大学博士,上海大学社会学院博士后/讲师。主要研究领域包括口头传统研究与数字人文的结合,戏剧影视文学中的修辞与社会转型的关系,以及民俗学理论与教学方法的研究等。

通讯作者:
邵文苑,E-mail:wyshao@shu.edu.cn

计量
- 文章访问数: 59
- HTML全文浏览量: 13
- PDF下载量: 1
- 被引次数: 0
出版历程
- 收稿日期: 2022-11-12
- 录用日期: 2022-12-26

Adjustments in Ethnic Relations and Literary Writings' “Relevance to Reality”: Reflecting upon Recent Works for Television and Theater Related to Madame She Xiang

SHAO Wenyuan^,

Shanghai University

摘要

摘要: 陈乐光与欧阳黔森著作权纠纷案的实质是关乎族群身份、人格尊严的公共关系的协商。一些人提出采用是否“忠于历史”的原则来评判公允，然而这一原则对部分采取口头叙事来记忆往事的族群十分不利，也忽略了每场战争的双方会以不同方式书写历史的现实。另一个原则是人所熟知的“现实意义”原则，但民族文学的“现实意义”是一个相当模糊的概念，并且很大程度上受到“少数服从多数”和“坚持各民族平等”等政治话语的影响。本文探讨了这些政治标语如何影响了少数民族民间叙事，以及与奢香夫人有关的创作。随后，通过分析陈乐光《奢香演义》的潜在意图，文章提出潜隐剧本呈现的是现象学意义上的真理，而非认识论的，直接的提问与对话就可达到去伪存真的目的。最后，透过苏晓星的《大明皇帝与彝家女杰》、郭毅的《少女奢香》以及国内外少数族裔写作，文章探讨民族文学书写如何远离“魔鬼的印记”，并提出一种以评估和调适民族关系为目标的文学批评模型，引导作家走向更为平衡的现实重构。
- 彝族文学 /
- 隐藏文本 /
- 辩证反讽 /
- 戏剧影视 /
- 共同体意识
Abstract: The essence of the Chen Leguang and Ouyang Qiansen copyright dispute case revolves around the negotiation of public relations concerning ethnic identity and personal dignity. Some people suggest using the principle of "being faithful to history" to judge fairness. However,this principle is highly disadvantageous for ethnic groups that rely on oral narratives to remember the past,and it overlooks the reality that both sides of a war will write history in different ways. Another principle is the well-known "relevance to reality" principle,but ethnic literature's "relevance to reality" is a rather vague concept and is greatly influenced by political discourses such as "minority obeys the majority" and "upholding equality among ethnic groups." This article explores how these political slogans have influenced ethnic minority folk narratives, particularly those related to Madame She Xiang. Subsequently, by analyzing the underlying intentions of Chen Leguang's Romance of She Xiang,the article proposes that the presentation of hidden transcripts represents phenomenological truth rather than epistemological truth, and that the goal of revealing the truth can be achieved through direct questioning and dialogue. Finally,through the exploration of Su Xiaoxing's The Ming Emperor and a Heroic Yi Woman, Guo Yi's She Xiang's Childhood and Adolescence, and writings by ethnic minority authors both domestically and internationally, the article discusses how ethnic literature can move away from the "traces of the devil" and proposes a model for literary criticism that aims to evaluate and adjust ethnic relations,guiding writers towards a more balanced reconstruction of reality.
- Yi literature /
- hidden transcripts /
- dialectical satire /
- drama and television /
- sense of community

HTML全文

参考文献(44)

[1]	Burke, Kenneth. A Grammar of Motives. University of California Press, 1969.
[2]	Foley, John Miles. How to Read an Oral Poem. Urbana and Chicago:University of Illinois Press, 2002.
[3]	Noyes,Dorothy. "Aesthetic Is the Opposite of Anaesthetic:On Tradition and Attention." Journal of Folklore Research 51, no. 2(2014):125-75.
[4]	Scott, James. Domination and the Arts of Resistance:Hidden Transcripts. Yale University Press, 1990.
[5]	安文新:《戏说·复杂·独特:读陈乐光长篇电视剧本〈奢香演义〉》, 红河州文联编:《第二次全国当代彝族文学研讨会论文集》, 昆明:云南民族出版社, 2005 年。
[6]	[AN Wenxin. "Xishuo,fuza,dute:Du Chen Leguang changpian dianshijuben She Xiang Yanyi" (Dramatic, Complex,and Unique:Reading Chen Leguang's Novelistic Television Play Romance of She Xiang). In Di'erci quanguo dangdai Yizu wenxue yantaohui lunwenji (Collection of Second National Symposium on Contemporary Yi Literature). Edited by Federation of Literary and Art Circles of Honghe Prefecture. Kunming:Yunnan Nationalities Publishing House, 2005.]
[7]	(彝) 巴莫曲布嫫、张玲译:《联合国教科文组织:〈保护非物质文化遗产伦理原则〉》,《民族文学研究》 2016年第 3 期, 第 5~6 页。
[8]	[BAMO Qubumo and ZHANG Ling,trans. "Lianheguo Jiao Ke Wen Zuzhi:Baohu feiwuzhi wenhua yichan lunli yuanze" (UNESCO:Ethical Principles for Safeguarding Intangible Cultural Heritage). Minzu wenxue yanjiu(Studies of Ethnic Literature)3(2016):5-6.]
[9]	陈乐光:《奢香演义》, 香港:香港天马图书有限公司, 2003 年。
[10]	[CHEN Leguang. She Xiang yanyi(Romance of She Xiang). Hong Kong:Hong Kong Tin Ma Book Company Limited, 2003.]
[11]	陈潘、朱启敏:《奢香研究现状考述》,《贵州工程应用技术学院学报》 2020 年第 1 期, 第 54~59 页。
[12]	[CHEN Pan and ZHU Qimin. "She Xiang yanjiu xianzhuang kaoshu" (Literature Review of Current Studies on She Xiang). Guizhou gongcheng yingyong jishu xueyuan xuebao (Journal of Guizhou University of Engineering Science)1(2020):54-59.]
[13]	关纪新、朝戈金:《多重世界的选择——当代少数民族作家文学的理论描述》, 北京:中央民族大学出版社, 1995 年。
[14]	[GUAN Jixin and CHAO Gejin. Duochong shijie de xuanze:Dangdai shaoshu minzu zuojia wenxue de lilun miaoshu(Choices Among Multiple Worlds:A Theoretical Description of Contemporary Ethnic Minority Writers' Literature). Beijing:Minzu University of China Press, 1995.]
[15]	贵州省民族宗教事务委员会编:《贵州世居少数民族文学史·彝族卷 (下)》, 贵阳:贵州民族出版社, 2017 年。
[16]	[Ethnic and Religious Affairs Committee of Guizhou,ed. Guizhou shiju shaoshu minzu wenxueshi,Yizu juan (xia)(Literary History of Aboriginal Ethnic Minorities in Guizhou,Yi Volume,Part 2). Guiyang:Guizhou Ethnic Publishing House, 2017.]
[17]	郭毅:《少女奢香》, 北京:中国文联出版社, 2015 年。
[18]	[GUO Yi. Shaonü She Xiang(She Xiang's Childhood and Adolescence). Beijing:China Federation of Literary and Art Circles Publishing House, 2015.]
[19]	(加) 琳达·哈琴:《反讽之锋芒:反讽的理论与政见》, 徐晓雯译, 开封:河南大学出版社, 2010 年。
[20]	[Linda Hutcheon. Fanfeng zhi fengmang:Fanfeng de lilun yu zhengjian(Irony's Edge:The Theory and Politics of Irony). Translated by XU Xiaowen. Kaifeng:Henan University Press, 2010.]
[21]	李长中:《当代少数民族文学批评如何面对民间话语》,《学术论坛》 2011 年第 2 期, 第 87~91 页。
[22]	[LI Changzhong. "Dangdai shaoshu minzu wenxue piping ruhe miandui minjian huayu" (How Contemporary Ethnic Minority Literary Criticism Should Deal with Folk Discourse). Xueshu luntan(Academic Forum)2(2011):87-91.]
[23]	马丹丹:《 "生态艺术" 与 "逃避艺术":尹绍亭、斯科特关于刀耕火种的 "对话" 》,《中央民族大学学报》 2017年第 6 期, 第 36~49 页。
[24]	[MA Dandan. "‘Shengtai yishu’ yu ‘taobi yishu’:Yin Shaoting,Sikete guanyu daogenghuozhong de ‘duihua’" (Ecological Art and the Art of Escape:A Dialogue between Yin Shaoting and James Scott on the Slash-and-Burn Technique). Zhongyang minzu daxue xuebao(Journal of Minzu University of China)6(2017):36-49.]
[25]	马戎:《中国社会的另一类 "二元结构" 》,《北京大学学报 (哲学社会科学版)》 2010 年第 3 期, 第 93~103 页。
[26]	[MA Rong. "Zhongguo shehui de lingyilei ‘eryuan jiegou’" (Another "Dualistic Structure" in Chinese Society). Beijing daxue xuebao,zhexue shehui kexue ban(Journal of Peking University[Philosophy and Social Science Edition])3(2010):93-103.]
[27]	欧阳可惺:《主体性的阻断:反对地方民族主义与少数民族文学》,《暨南学报》 2014 年第 2 期, 第 27~35 页。
[28]	[OUYANG Kexing. "Zhutixing de zuduan:Fandui difang minzu zhuyi yu shaoshu minzu wenxue" (Obstruction of Agency:Anti-Regionalism and Ethnic Minority Literature). Jinan xuebao(Jinan Journal)2(2014):27-35.]
[29]	欧阳黔森:《奢香夫人》, 贵阳:贵州人民出版社, 2011 年。
[30]	[OUYANG Qiansen. She Xiang furen(Madame She Xiang). Guiyang:Guizhou People's Press, 2011.]
[31]	施爱东:《民俗学立场的文化批评》, 北京:中国社会科学出版社, 2020 年。
[32]	[SHI Aidong. Minsuxue lichang de wenhua piping(Cultural Critiques from Folkloric Perspectives). Beijing:China Social Sciences Press, 2020.]
[33]	苏晓星:《大明皇帝和彝家女杰》, 北京:作家出版社, 2007 年。
[34]	[SU Xiaoxing. Da Ming Huangdi he Yijia nüjie(The Ming Emperor and a Heroic Yi Woman). Beijing:Writers Publishing House, 2007.]
[35]	王继超主编:《布默战史》, 贵阳:贵州民族出版社, 2007 年。
[36]	[WANG Jichao,ed. Bu Mo zhan shi(History of the Wars Between the Bu and Mo Branches). Guiyang:Guizhou Ethnic Publishing House, 2007.]
[37]	王明贵:《有关奢香夫人的文艺作品概论》,《乌蒙论坛》 2009 年第 3 期, 第 57~61 页。
[38]	[WANG Minggui. "Youguan Shexiang furen de wenyi zuopin gailun" (An Introduction to Literary Works About Madame She Xiang). Wumeng luntan(Wumeng Forum)3(2009):57-61.]
[39]	巫达:《社会变迁与文化认同:凉山彝族的个案研究》, 上海:学林出版社, 2008 年。
[40]	[WU Da. Shehui bianqian yu wenhua rentong:Liangshan Yizu de ge' an yanjiu(Social Transformation and Cultural Identification:Case Studies on the Liangshan Yi). Shanghai:Xuelin Publishing House, 2008.]
[41]	吴兴春采访、陈乐光口述:《我的〈奢香演义〉创作历程》,《贵州民族报》 2012 年 1 月 20 日。
[42]	[WU Xingchun and CHEN Leguang. "Wo de She Xiang Yanyi chuangzuo licheng" (How I Wrote the Romance of She Xiang). Guizhou minzu bao(Guizhou Newspaper for Nationalities), January 20, 2012.]
[43]	谢刚、张逸云:《论 "十七年" 时期少数民族文学批评的社会主义国家认同》,《民族文学研究》 2022 年第 5期, 第 67~76 页。
[44]	[XIE Gang and ZHANG Yiyun. "Lun ‘Shiqi Nian’ shiqi shaoshu minzu wenxue piping de shehui zhuyi guojia rentong" (On the Identification with the Socialist Nation in Textual Criticism of Ethnic Minority Literature during the Seventeen-Year Period). Minzu wenxue yanjiu(Studies of Ethnic Literature)5(2022):67-76.]

施引文献

资源附件(0)

访问统计

点击查看大图

计量

文章访问数: 59
HTML全文浏览量: 13
PDF下载量: 1
被引次数: 0

姓名
邮箱
手机号码
标题
留言内容
验证码

留言板

民族关系的调适与文学创作的“现实意义”——反思近年来有关奢香夫人的几部戏剧影视作品

doi: 10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20236207

作者简介:
邵文苑,美国俄亥俄州立大学博士,上海大学社会学院博士后/讲师。主要研究领域包括口头传统研究与数字人文的结合,戏剧影视文学中的修辞与社会转型的关系,以及民俗学理论与教学方法的研究等。

通讯作者:
邵文苑,E-mail:wyshao@shu.edu.cn

计量

Adjustments in Ethnic Relations and Literary Writings' “Relevance to Reality”: Reflecting upon Recent Works for Television and Theater Related to Madame She Xiang

计量

目录

留言板

民族关系的调适与文学创作的“现实意义”——反思近年来有关奢香夫人的几部戏剧影视作品

doi: 10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20236207

作者简介: 邵文苑,美国俄亥俄州立大学博士,上海大学社会学院博士后/讲师。主要研究领域包括口头传统研究与数字人文的结合,戏剧影视文学中的修辞与社会转型的关系,以及民俗学理论与教学方法的研究等。

通讯作者: 邵文苑,E-mail:wyshao@shu.edu.cn

计量

出版历程

Adjustments in Ethnic Relations and Literary Writings' “Relevance to Reality”: Reflecting upon Recent Works for Television and Theater Related to Madame She Xiang

计量

出版历程

目录

作者简介:
邵文苑,美国俄亥俄州立大学博士,上海大学社会学院博士后/讲师。主要研究领域包括口头传统研究与数字人文的结合,戏剧影视文学中的修辞与社会转型的关系,以及民俗学理论与教学方法的研究等。

通讯作者:
邵文苑,E-mail:wyshao@shu.edu.cn