物证优先：四重证据法与“玉成中国三部曲”

叶舒宪

doi:10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20203301

物证优先：四重证据法与“玉成中国三部曲”

doi: 10.19857/j.cnki.ICL.20203301

叶舒宪

上海交通大学, 中国社会科学院

计量
- 文章访问数: 566
- HTML全文浏览量: 70
- PDF下载量: 1099
- 被引次数: 0
出版历程
- 收稿日期: 2020-04-28
- 修回日期: 2020-07-10
- 刊出日期: 2021-03-09

Material Evidence Priority: Quadruple Evidence Method and the “Jade-Making China Trilogy”

YE Shuxian

Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

摘要

摘要: 作为中国比较文学跨学科研究杰出代表的文学人类学一派，在最近十年来设计并完成的三大科研攻关项目，简单概括为“玉成中国三部曲”，其中包括《中华文明探源的神话学研究》（2015）、《玉石神话信仰与华夏精神》（2019）和《玄玉时代——五千年中国的新求证》（2020）。伴随着2005年文学人类学派首次提出的跨学科研究方法论范式——四重证据法，迄今已经总结出以第四重证据为主的探索方向和研究策略，即“物证优先”原则。这就使得当今的中国文史哲研究者终于有条件走出文献知识的千年瓶颈束缚，真正践行“五千年中国”乃至“万年中国”的认知目标。本文通过梳理“玉成中国三部曲”成果在2015年以来陆续问世的过程，说明文学人类学派的新方法论之操作原理：将传世文献资料作为一重证据，将甲骨文金文等新出土文字材料作为二重证据，将口传文化、仪式展演等人类学研究特色资源作为三重证据，将考古发掘的遗址、文物和图像等作为第四重证据。基于四重证据法的立体性研究经验，在2010年提出“文化大传统”的全新理念，特指无文字时代的文化传统。而探索无文字的文化传统的问题意识，自觉地引领研究者走出文献本位的传统研究窠臼，将文字书写传统视为后起的小传统，并将深度阐释文学与文化的目标加以理论化，即从文字文本研究朝向“文化文本”构拟的整体认识的创新之路。
- 文学人类学 /
- 物证 /
- 四重证据法 /
- 文化文本 /
- 玉成中国
Abstract: The school of literary anthropology, an outstanding representative of interdisciplinary research in Chinese comparative literature, has designed and completed three major scientific research projects in the past ten years, which are simply summarized as the "Jade-Making China Trilogy," comprising "Mythological Research on the Origin of Chinese Civilization" (2015), "Jade Myth Belief and Huaxia Spirit" (2019) and "Xuanyu Era:Five Thousand Years of China's New Verification" (2020). The quadruple evidence method, the first interdisciplinary research methodology paradigm proposed by the literary anthropology school in 2005, summarizes the exploration direction and research strategy so far-that is, the principle of "material evidence first." This means that domestic scholars of literature, history, and philosophy finally have the conditions to get rid of the millennium bottleneck of literary knowledge, and truly implement the cognitive goals of "five thousand years of China" and even "ten thousand years of China." This article demonstrates the operation of the new methodology of the literary anthropology school by combing and reviewing the process of the "Jade-Making China Trilogy," successively published since 2015:employing the handed-down literary materials as primary evidence, and the newly unearthed textual sources such as Oracle Bone and Bronze Inscriptions as secondary evidence, oral culture, ritual performance, and other anthropological special research resources as the third evidence, and archaeological excavated sites, cultural relics, and images as the fourth evidence. Based on the three-dimensional research experience of the quadruple evidence method, the school proposed the new concept of the "Big Tradition" in 2010, especially referring to the cultural tradition in the era of no text. The project of exploring the problem of the cultural tradition without words leads researchers to jump out of the traditional literature-based research formula, regard the writing tradition as a minor tradition, and theorize the goal of in-depth interpretation of literature and culture, which is the innovative road from the research of written text to the overall understanding constructed by "cultural texts."
- literary anthropology /
- material evidence /
- quadruple evidence method /
- cultural text /
- “Jade-Making China”

HTML全文

参考文献(48)

[1]	陈寅恪:《金明馆丛稿二编》,上海古籍出版社1980年。
[2]	[CHEN Yinque. Jinming guancong gao erbian (Jinming Pavilion Series 2). Shanghai:Shanghai Classics Publishing House, 1980.]
[3]	顾颉刚:《中国上古史研究讲义》,北京:中华书局,2002年。
[4]	[GU Jiegang. Zhongguo shanggu Shi yanjiu jiangyi (Lecture Notes on Chinese Ancient History Research). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2002.]
[5]	孟华主编:《三重证据法》,长春:吉林大学出版社,2009年。
[6]	[MENG Hua. Sanchong zhengjufa (Triple Evidence Method). Changchun:Jilin University Press, 2009.]
[7]	上海古籍出版社编:《纬书集成》,上海:上海古籍出版社,1994年。
[8]	[Shanghai guji chubanshe bian. Weishujicheng (Weishu Integration). Shanghai:Shanghai Classics Publishing House, 1994.]
[9]	谭佳主编:《神话中国》,北京:生活·读书·新知·三联书店,2019年。
[10]	[TAN Jia. Shenhua Zhongguo (Mythical China). Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2019.]
[11]	文学人类学研究会主编,陕西师范大学人文社会科学高等研究院承办,《文化文本》创刊号,将由商务印书馆,2020年出版。
[12]	[Wenxuerenleixue yanjiuhui. Wenhuawenben (Cultural Text). Beijing:Commercial Press, 2020.]
[13]	徐炳主编:《黄帝思想与道、理、法研究》,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2013年。
[14]	[XU Bing. Huangdi sixiang yu dao, li, fa yanjiu (Research on Emperor Huang's Thought and Tao, Theory and Law). Beijing:Social Sciences Literature Press, 2013.]
[15]	——:《黄帝思想与先秦诸子百家》,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2015年。
[16]	[——. Huangdi Sixiang yu Xianqin Zhuzibaijia (Emperor Huang's Thoughts and the Hundred Schools of the Pre-Qin Dynasty). Beijing:Social Sciences Literature Press, 2015.]
[17]	叶舒宪:《文学人类学教程》,北京:中国社会科学出版社,2010年。
[18]	[YE Shuxian. Wenxuerenleixue jiaocheng (Literary Anthropology Course). Beijing:Chinese Social Sciences Press, 2010.]
[19]	——:《神话-原型批评》,西安:陕西师范大学出版社1987年初版和2011年再版。
[20]	[——. Shenhua-yuanxing piping (Myth-Prototype Criticism). Xi'an:Shaanxi Normal University Press, 1987& 2011.]
[21]	——:《玉石之路踏查记》,兰州:甘肃人民出版社,2015年。
[22]	[——. Yushi zhi lu tacha ji (Investigation on the Road Jade). Lanzhou:Gansu People's Publishing House, 2015.]
[23]	——:《中华文明探源的神话学研究》,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2015年。
[24]	[——. Zhonghua wenming tanyuan de shenhuaxue yanjiu (Mythological Research on the Origin of Chinese Civilization). Beijing:Social Sciences Literature Press, 2015.]
[25]	——:《图说中华文明发生史》,广州:南方日报出版社,2015年。
[26]	[——. Tushuo Zhonghua wenming fasheng Shi (An Illustrated History of the Origin of Chinese Civilization). Guangzhou:Southern Daily Press, 2015.]
[27]	——:《诗经的文化阐释》自序《人类学与三重证据法与考据学的更新》,武汉:湖北人民出版社,1994年。
[28]	[——. Shijing de wenhua chanshi (Cultural Interpretation of The Book of Songs). Wuhan:Hubei People's Publishing House, 1994.]
[29]	——:《玄玉时代——五千年中国的新求证》,上海:上海人民出版社,2020年。
[30]	[——. Xuanyu shidai-wuqiannian Zhongguo de xin qiuzheng (Xuanyu Era:Five Thousand Years of China's New Verification). Shanghai:Shanghai People's Publishing House, 2020.]
[31]	——:《玄玉与黄帝——第十四次玉帛之路(北洛河道)考察简报》,《丝绸之路》2018年第11期。
[32]	[——. "Xuanyu yu Huangdi-di shisi ci yubo zhi lu (bei luohe dao) kaocha jianbao" (Xuanyu and Emperor Huang-The 14th Jade Silk Road[Beiluo River Road] Investigation Report). Sichou zhi lu (Silk Road) 11(2018).]
[33]	——:《玉教、玉石之路、新教革命(白玉崇拜)》,见于《中国玉文化》,2014年第5辑。
[34]	[——. "Yujiao, yushi zhi lu, xinjiao geming (baiyu geming)"(Jade Religion, Jade Road, Protestant Revolution[White Jade Worship]). Zhongguo Yu wenhua (Chinese Jade Culture) 5(2014).]
[35]	——:《白玉崇拜及其神话历史》,《安徽大学学报》2015年第2期。
[36]	[——. "Baiyu chongbai ji qi shenhua lishi" (White Jade Worship and its Mythical History). Anhui daxue xuebao (Journal of Anhui University) 2(2015).]
[37]	——:《草原玉石之路与红玛瑙珠的传播中国(公元前2000年~前1000年)——兼评杰西卡·罗森的文化传播观》,《内蒙古社会科学》2018年第4期。
[38]	[——. "Caoyuan yushi zhi lu yu hong manaozhu de chuanbo Zhongguo (gongyuanqian 2000 nian-qian 1000 nian)-jianping Jiexikaluosen de wenhua chuanboguan" (Prairie Jade Road and the Spread of Red Agate Beads in China[2000-
[39]	1000 BC]). Neimenggu shehui kexue (Social Sciences in Neimenggu) 4(2018).]
[40]	——:《重述神话中国》,上海:上海交通大学出版社,2018年。
[41]	[——. Chongshu shenhua Zhongguo (Retelling the Mythical China). Shanghai, Shanghai Jiao Tong University Press, 2018.]
[42]	——、古方主编:《玉成中国——玉石之路与玉兵文化探源》,北京:中华书局,2015年。
[43]	[——and GU Fang. Yu cheng Zhongguo-yushi zhi lu yu yubing wenhua tanyuan (Jade Making China-the Jade Road and the Origin of Jade Soldier Culture). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2015.]
[44]	——:《玉石神话信仰与华夏精神》,上海:复旦大学出版社,2019年。
[45]	[——. Yushi shenhua xinyang yu huaxia jingshen (Jade Myth Belief and Huaxia Spirit). Shanghai:Fudan University Press, 2019.]
[46]	——:《万年中国说》,《名作欣赏》2019年第8期;收入:《玉石里的中国》,上海:上海文艺出版社,2019年。
[47]	[——. "Wannian Zhongguo shuo" (Thousands of Years of China). Mingzuo xinshang (Masterpiece Appreciation) 8(2019).]
[48]	[——. Yushi li de Zhongguo (China in Jade). Shanghai:Shanghai Literature and Arts Publishing House, 2019.]